Study Identifies Strengths and Challenges of Responding to Dual Disasters
Leslie Capo, Director of Information Services
A new study of how the 2020 major hurricanes and the COVID-19 pandemic affected each other as well as disaster response found that although prior experience enabled community-based organizations to respond to the pandemic, the pandemic is also creating new challenges to preparing for and responding to natural disasters. The research is published in the International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, available here.
“Two major crises hit Louisiana and coastal communities in the Southeastern United
States in 2020 - a significant increase in the frequency and severity of hurricanes,
and the COVID-19 pandemic,” says Benjamin Springgate, MD, MPH, Chief of Community
& Population Medicine at LSU Health New Orleans School of Medicine.
Semi-structured interviews were conducted with 26 representatives of community-based
programs in southern Louisiana. The participants ranged in age from 28 to 70. The
majority (61.5%) were non-Hispanic white; 30.8% were Black; one participant (3.8%)
was Latinx and one participant (3.8%) was Vietnamese. Three-fourths of the participants
lived in Orleans Parish, and most represented local-level organizations. Participants
represented 24 community-based agencies and organizations that provide a wide variety
of services, including environmental and social justice issues impacting underserved
communities, community health promotion, health and mental health services, disaster
preparedness and recovery, funding of community initiatives, community development,
faith-based services, affordable housing, child welfare advocacy and support, and
criminal justice reform.
“Local leaders noted that due to the pandemic, it is now harder to plan for evacuations
in the event of a hurricane,” adds Dr. Springgate. “Organizations find it is also
more difficult to provide in-person client services and challenging to plan for providing
food and other resources to residents who may shelter in place during a storm.”
The analysis also identified several strengths based on disaster preparedness experience
and capabilities.
“Local organizations identified several strengths based on their disaster preparedness
experience - particularly that based on prior experience with hurricanes, they already
had a framework for how to respond and adapt to the novel challenges presented by
COVID,” Dr. Springgate notes.
The analysis shows that the increase in demand for disaster-related services has been
accompanied by a decrease in the availability of services due to a decline in available
financial resources as well as the constraints on services delivery imposed by protocols
designed to prevent the spread of the SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus.
The authors conclude that despite the anticipated challenges to delivering services
in response to a natural disaster, the networks of partnerships and prior experiences
with disaster preparedness and response, along with certain features of the community
that have fostered resilience to adverse events, represent key assets in coping with
the pandemic and with the current hurricane season. Though limited to a particular
setting with extensive experience with climate-related disasters and preparedness
and response, the lessons for interaction with a pandemic context may have important
implications for approaches in other areas to consider enhancing preparedness and
response resources, training and partnerships.
Other LSU Health New Orleans authors include Dr. Ashley Wennerstrom, Olivia Sugarman,
Carter Pesson, Jessica E. Seay, and Caroline N. Stallard. Other authors were Lawrence
A. Palinkas from the University of Southern California, Jill Hancock from Pennington
Biomedical Research Center, Diana Meyers from St. Anna's Episcopal Church, Arthur
Johnson from Lower Ninth Ward Center for Sustainable Engagement and Development, Mara
Polk from National Alliance on Metal Illness-New Orleans, and Kenneth B. Wells from
the University of California, Los Angeles.
This research was supported by a grant from the National Academy of Sciences' Gulf
Research Program (NCT03977844, B. Springgate, PI).